Twilight Masquerade Eevee pop report: eight Eevee and a sixth of the set

Twilight Masquerade is an Ogerpon set. The card its buyers kept mailing to PSA is an Eevee. At the September 19, 2026 pull the Twilight Masquerade Eevee pop report reads 30,314 grades on Eevee 188/167, the illustration rare, which is 17.15 percent of the 176,766 English grades the whole expansion has taken and more than any other card in it.

What the Twilight Masquerade Eevee pop report counts

12,117 Gem Mint 10s, 15,130 nines, 2,418 eights, 643 copies at a 7 or lower and 6 Authentic, for a lifetime rate of 40.0 percent at the September 19, 2026 pull.

Set that beside the cards the expansion was actually sold on. Greninja ex 214/167, the most graded special illustration rare in the set, has taken 23,067 grades. All 21 ultra rares and all six hyper rares hold 16,258 grades between the 27 of them, a little over half of what the one Eevee has. Inside its own tier the card holds 31.80 percent of the 21 row illustration rare census of 95,323 and 2.05 times the submissions of Chansey 187/167, the next row down at 14,781.

Eevee does not do this by itself

The easy reading is that the name sells, and Prismatic Evolutions is the test that settles it, because the set built on the Eeveelutions printed one Eevee card in two places. Its pack common, 074/131, has taken 320 PSA grades in its entire life. The Elite Trainer Box print of the same card, SVP 173, has taken 84,252. Same Pokemon, same months, same buyers, and a 263 times gap that tracks only which box it came out of.

The illustrator does not carry it either. Narumi Sato drew this Eevee and also drew the ordinary Eevee 133/165 in Scarlet and Violet 151, which carries 133 grades in the same dataset. Every Eevee row that outgrades the Twilight Masquerade one is a product: that ETB promo, its Pokemon Center print at 18,183, and the Eevee ex from the Super-Premium Collection at 22,913.

So what does sort a tier? Price. Rank the 21 illustration rares by raw market price and by census and the two orders agree at a Spearman rho of 0.897, with this Eevee top of both lists. The same measurement held across three Mega Evolution block sets, and it holds here on a 2024 release. Eevee is worth something at the till. It only becomes a census when it lands in the slot collectors are already chasing.

Narumi Sato drew eight Eevee, one for each evolution

Bulbapedia credits the illustration rare to Narumi Sato and the ordinary 135/167 print of the same card to satoma. Sato put the scene in a parlour in late afternoon light: Eevee on the sofa, Eevee over the back of a chair, Eevee asleep in a laundry basket, tulips in a vase on the sill.

Count them and there are eight, one for each Eeveelution that existed by the Scarlet and Violet era, and Bulbapedia's trivia reads several of the poses as possible nods to what each one turns into. The Eevee in the window light is sitting where Espeon would sit. Flowers for Leafeon, a Hydreigon doll for Sylveon, a mug being inspected for Vaporeon, and the Umbreon of the group has taken itself off under the table away from everybody. A piece of the artwork went out early, in the promotional image Pokemon published ahead of Pokemon Day 2024.

The card does not come from the Japanese set this one is named after. English Twilight Masquerade merges two Japanese releases, and the Eevee arrives from the second of them, Crimson Haze, where it is card 078/066 and went on sale in Japan on March 22, 2024. The English print followed on May 24, 2024.

Basically Marie spent a June 2024 Target run hunting this exact card, five weeks after the English release, which is the behaviour the census above is a record of.

The grade it misses is the last one

A 40.0 percent lifetime rate puts this Eevee 20th of the 21 illustration rares in its own set, which reads like a condition problem until the number is split in two.

Damage is not where it loses. 2.12 percent of its copies have come back a 7 or lower against 2.13 percent across the tier, so the cards are not arriving more beaten up than their shelfmates. The gap is at the top step and only there. Of the copies that came back a 9 or a 10, 44.47 percent were tens. The other twenty rows in the tier ran 48.05 percent on the same split, 3.6 points ahead at the one step that pays anything.

Why it goes wrong at that step is a guess, and the guess with something behind it is submission mix. This row carries twice the volume of anything else in the tier, and volume that size tends to arrive in stacks rather than one screened card at a time. Nobody publishes who sends what, so that stays an inference. The tier level around it is not an inference: 42.12 percent pooled is roughly where an illustration rare tier from this era settles, and this card sits a point under the tier it came in, not outside it.

The ten pays nearly four times raw, the nine does not

PSA's Value tier was open on November 22, 2026 at $39.99 a card, a $500 ceiling and an estimated 90 to 100 business days, read off psacard.com that morning. A ten here sits nowhere near that ceiling, so Value is the tier to price against rather than the $59.99 Standard.

Grading mathAmount
Raw copy (live PriceCharting ungraded)$67
PSA grading, Value service$40
PSA 10 sale (as of November 22, 2026, the PSA titled sold tape)$269
PSA 9 sale (as of November 22, 2026, the PSA titled sold tape)$77
Margin if it gems+$161
Margin at PSA 9-$30

Thirty PSA titled sales between November 2 and November 22 put the 10 at a $268.50 median. The 9 medians $77.00 across 25 sales since October 29, while a Near Mint raw copy cleared $70.50 across 43 sales in the same window. One grade point is the whole return here, and it is worth about $190 of it.

Weight all four outcomes by this card's own census, dock 13 percent for platform fees, and a submission hands back roughly $132 against $107 of card and grading. Breakeven sits at 25.6 percent. The card has run 40.0 percent for its entire life, which is most of the reason thirty thousand copies have already gone in.

Two costs sit outside that math. Ninety to a hundred business days means a card posted this week comes back in spring. And the 8, which takes 7.98 percent of submissions, medians $57.78 across six sales since October 29, under what the raw card costs.

Which copy to send

With damage this rare and the money sitting entirely on the 9 to 10 line, the pre screen worth running is corners. PSA's published Gem Mint 10 standard asks for four perfectly sharp corners before it asks for anything else. Check all four against something black, where a frayed tip shows up white, and hold back any copy where one corner does not match the other three.

If you own a clean one, the odds and the fee both say send it. If you would rather buy than grade, the 9 costs about seven dollars more than a raw Near Mint copy, which makes it a cheap way to own a graded Eevee and a poor way to end up with a ten. Our guide to reading a pop report covers what a lifetime rate can and cannot tell you, and all 21 of these illustration rares sit side by side in the BetterPop gallery.

Sources

  • PSA population via the GemRate pull of September 19, 2026; every figure in the data block above refreshes with each site build
  • The tier shares, the 0.897 price to census ordering, the damage and conversion splits, and the Eevee row comparisons across Prismatic Evolutions, Scarlet and Violet 151 and the SV Black Star Promos were computed inside this repo's dataset snapshot, one pull, no differencing
  • Bulbapedia: Eevee (Surging Sparks 143) for the Prismatic Evolutions 074/131 and SVP 173 prints of one card, and Eevee (151 133) for the Narumi Sato credit on 133/165, both read November 22, 2026
  • PriceCharting: Eevee #188, Pokemon Twilight Masquerade, grade ladder and the dated PSA titled sold tape at the 8, 9 and 10, read November 22, 2026; CGC, BGS, SGC, TAG and ACE rows were dropped before taking any median, and the 8, 9 and 10 tapes were cut to the same window
  • PSA service levels and pricing for the Value fee, ceiling and turnaround, and PSA grading standards for the Gem Mint 10 definition, both read November 22, 2026
  • Bulbapedia: Eevee (Twilight Masquerade 135) for the Narumi Sato and satoma credits, the eight Eevee trivia, the Crimson Haze origin and the Pokemon Day 2024 sneak peek, and Twilight Masquerade (TCG) for the May 24, 2024 English release and the rarity counts, which match GemRate's row counts at 21 illustration rares, 11 special illustration rares and six hyper rares; both read November 22, 2026
  • Artwork, illustrator credit, card number and border verified against the card scan on pokemontcg.io

Every number above is one row of 111,891. Sort the whole census yourself, free, no login.

Open the BetterPop gallery