Journey Together Articuno pop report: the lifetime rate is a third too kind
The Journey Together Articuno pop report gives two answers and they sit two and a half times apart. Lifetime, Articuno 161/159 reads 27.1 percent Gem Mint at the October 26, 2026 pull. Across the 1,106 copies PSA graded between September 16 and October 26, 2026, it ran 10.49. Same card, same grader, and only the second figure describes a submission you would mail tomorrow.
Thirty thousand submissions, counted two ways
30,382 graded at the October 26, 2026 pull. 8,235 tens, 16,820 nines, 4,379 eights, 5 Authentic and 943 copies sitting at a 7 or lower. That is the most graded English card in Journey Together, 12.30 percent of the set's 246,963 grades on its own, and the census grew 76.92 percent over the 51 weeks ending at that pull. Still arriving in volume, not being tidied up.
Now split that census by when it arrived. Differencing the archived pull of September 16, 2026 against the current one gives 1,106 fresh grades: 116 tens, 642 nines, 281 eights and 62 copies at a 7 or lower. GemRate publishes its own trailing 30 day gem rate for this row and reads 10.0 against the 10.49 those two snapshots produce by hand, so the collapse survives being measured a second way.
The eights are where it shows. Over the card's whole life 14.41 percent of submissions have landed on an 8. In that September to October window the figure was 25.41. Copies arriving now are losing a grade across the whole ladder, which is the signature of worse cardboard rather than worse luck.
The split runs through the whole set
Journey Together printed eleven illustration rares, six special illustration rares and three hyper rares, and Bulbapedia's expansion page counts them exactly as GemRate's rows do. Pooled, the eleven have taken 109,650 grades at 28.67 percent, so Articuno at 27.1 sits mid pack rather than apart. Where a set's illustration rare tier settles is an era property, and that is the tier's level, not this card's problem.
Difference the same window across all eleven and the tier returns 3,019 fresh grades for 360 tens, an 11.92 percent pooled rate. Every one of the eleven came in under its own lifetime figure, the best at 18.92 percent and the worst at 8.82.
Then run it on the six special illustration rares from the same packs. 2,725 fresh grades, 974 tens, 35.74 percent pooled, and all six came in above lifetime, from 33.45 up to 43.31. The two tiers overlap heavily on lifetime numbers, 25.86 to 33.88 against 30.24 to 34.16. In the recent window they do not touch at all.
The cleanest version of that is a pair. This Articuno took 1,106 fresh grades in the window and Lillie's Clefairy ex 184/159 took 1,103, within three of each other. One returned 116 tens. The other returned 369.
Why the cheap half decays first
Something has to be different about who is still mailing these in, because the printing stopped being a variable in March 2025. Price is the candidate with evidence behind it. TCGplayer's sold tape on November 20, 2026 put Near Mint copies of this Articuno at $12.00, Wailord 162/159 at $8.30 and N's Reshiram 167/159 at $11.48, while Lillie's Clefairy ex cleared $76.24. The three rows whose recent eight share roughly doubled are the $8 to $12 cards; the one whose eight share did not move at all is the $76 card.
That reads like a screening story. A twelve dollar card gets sent in batches off aftermarket stock that has been shipped, sleeved and reshipped, and a seventy six dollar card gets looked at one copy at a time. It is an association across five rows in one set, not a proof, and nobody publishes who submits what.
Set age points the same way. Pooling every English set carrying at least three rows in each tier past 100 fresh grades, the illustration rare deficit sorts by release date: Journey Together, March 28, 2025, down 17.38 points; Destined Rivals, May 30, down 12.38; Black Bolt, July 18, down 6.90; Mega Evolution, September 26, up 5.03. Four releases roughly two months apart, in order, and the five Mega Evolution block sets after them show essentially nothing on either tier. Scarlet & Violet 151 from September 2023 falls further still, but its special illustration rares fall with it, so what makes Journey Together the sharp case is one tier that has aged beside one that has not. A promo where the trailing rate ran well ahead of lifetime is the same measurement pointed the other way.
Kuroimori drew it in near white
Bulbapedia's card page credits the illustration rare print to Kuroimori and the ordinary 032/159 print to Takumi Wada, two different artists for the same Articuno in one expansion. Kuroimori's first Pokemon card was the Gardevoir ex 233/091 from Paldean Fates, which is one set of the shiny subset era earlier.
Articuno glides left to right through a forest drawn almost entirely in white and the palest blue, frost on every branch, ice columns stacked behind it. The art runs to all four cut edges inside a narrow silver band, and the number reads 161/159 because illustration rares are numbered past the set's stated 159.
The English print came out on March 28, 2025. It is the Battle Partners art rare, card 102/100 in Japan. One bookkeeping note for anyone checking these figures against GemRate: the silver stamped N's Reshiram from the Enhanced Booster Display Box is filed as its own row, so it sits outside every tier number above.
Forty dollars against a twenty one percent breakeven
PSA's Value tier was open on November 20, 2026 at $39.99 a card with a $500 insured ceiling and an estimated 90 to 100 business days, read off psacard.com that day. A PSA 10 here is nowhere near the ceiling, so Value is the honest tier to price against rather than the $59.99 Standard.
| Grading math | Amount |
|---|---|
| Raw copy (as of November 20, 2026) | $12 |
| PSA grading, Value service | $40 |
| PSA 10 sale (as of November 20, 2026, the PSA titled sold tape) | $192 |
| PSA 9 sale (as of November 20, 2026, the PSA titled sold tape) | $30 |
| Margin if it gems | +$140 |
| Margin at PSA 9 | -$22 |
PriceCharting's own PSA 10 column read $188.80 the same morning against a $192.32 median across thirty PSA titled sales between November 5 and November 20, close enough that the estimate and the realised tape are telling the same story. Thirty sales in fifteen days also answers the liquidity question before anyone asks it.
Everything under the top grade is the problem. The PSA 9 tape medians $29.99 across twenty three sales and the PSA 8 medians $22.00 across twenty six, against a $12.00 raw copy and a $39.99 fee. Dock 15 percent off each payout for the platform and shipping a slab and the breakeven gem rate lands at 20.9 percent. Weight the outcomes by the lifetime census and a submission hands back about $61 against $52 of cost. Weight them by what actually came back between September and October and it hands back about $37. The lifetime number clears the fee by six points. The recent one misses by ten.
Ninety to a hundred business days is the rest of the bill, most of two seasons spent holding a card whose grade distribution has been sliding the whole time you would be waiting.
Measure the silver band before you mail it
Centering is the pre screen that matters here and it is unusually easy to run, because the silver band framing the art is narrow and uniform. Lay a ruler across it left to right and then top to bottom. A cut that drifted shows up as one band visibly fatter than its opposite, and on a card where a quarter of recent submissions are coming back eights, that is the cheapest no you will get all day.
If you already own a copy, this is worth submitting only when your copy beats the ones being mailed in now, and the band test is how you find out. If you are buying slabs instead, the 9 at thirty dollars is the trap rather than the bargain. Our guide to reading a pop report covers what a trailing figure can and cannot tell you, and you can line this tier up against the special illustration rares yourself in the BetterPop gallery.
Sources
- PSA population via the GemRate pull of October 26, 2026; every figure in the data block above refreshes with each site build
- The 1,106 grade window, the tier pools, the eleven and six row orderings, the eight share shift and the cross set release date ordering were differenced against the archived pull of September 16, 2026 held in this repo's dataset snapshots
- PriceCharting: Articuno #161, Pokemon Journey Together, live grade ladder and the dated PSA titled sold tape at the 8, 9 and 10, read November 20, 2026; CGC, TAG and ACE rows were dropped before taking any median
- TCGplayer sold sales for products 623588, 623589, 624677 and 623611, Near Mint only, read November 20, 2026
- PSA service levels and pricing, Value fee, insured ceiling and turnaround, read November 20, 2026
- Bulbapedia: Journey Together (TCG) for the rarity counts, the March 28, 2025 English release, the Battle Partners and Generations Start Deck origins and the Enhanced Booster Display Box topper, and Articuno (Journey Together 32) for the Kuroimori and Takumi Wada credits and the Japanese card number, both read November 20, 2026
- Border, palette, illustrator credit and card number verified against the card scan on pokemontcg.io
Every number above is one row of 111,891. Sort the whole census yourself, free, no login.
Open the BetterPop gallery