Paldean Fates Mew ex pop report: five Supporters graded better

PSA has graded the Paldean Fates Mew ex 50,942 times and sent back 16,707 Gem Mint tens. At the October 1, 2026 pull the Paldean Fates Mew ex pop report reads 32.8 percent, and no card printed in an English shiny subset has been graded more often than the one collectors call Bubble Mew. It still finishes last of the eight special illustration rares in its own set.

Where this census stops

26,456 copies are sitting in a PSA 9 holder, 51.93 percent of everything ever submitted. Another 6,255 came back an 8. Only 1,510 of the 50,942 landed at 7 or lower, 2.96 percent of the census.

That last figure rules out the easy answer. Cards that reach PSA bent or scuffed leave a long tail of 5s and 6s behind them, and there is no tail here. Bulbapedia records that Paldean Fates booster packs were never sold on their own, only inside set related products, so a copy travelled in a sealed box before anyone handled it. The cards arrived in good order. The grades stopped one short anyway.

The next biggest English shiny census belongs to the Shining Fates Charizard VMAX, 49,600 grades at a 74.54 percent gem rate. Three years and forty one points separate the two biggest shiny censuses in English.

Five Supporters from the same packs graded better

The tier is eight cards, three shiny Pokemon ex and five Supporters. The Pokemon land at 32.8 percent here, 39.88 on the Charizard ex at 234 and 42.50 on the Gardevoir ex at 233. The Supporters land at 44.50 for Iono, 44.91 for Penny, 45.71 for Clive, 48.80 for Nemona and 51.14 for Arven, all at the same October 1, 2026 pull.

The five cheap ones came out of the same boosters, and they won.

That order is unusual. Fourteen English special illustration rare tiers carry at least two Pokemon rows and two Supporter rows past 1,000 grades, and the Pokemon pool ahead in eleven of them. Three invert, and Paldean Fates inverts hardest at 8.34 points. It is also the only one of the fourteen where the groups do not overlap at all: the best Pokemon row sits two points under the worst Supporter, with nothing in between.

What does not explain the gap

Shiny printing is the obvious suspect, because the three Pokemon are the shiny cards and the five Supporters are not. It dies one tier down. In the same set's ultra rare slot the shiny full arts run 32.17 to 47.39 percent and the Supporter full arts run 37.17 to 40.38, ranges sitting on top of each other out of the same packs.

The earlier prints kill it a second time. Gardevoir ex had a plain special illustration rare back in Scarlet and Violet, 36.68 percent on 18,692 grades, and the shiny reprint beats it by almost six points. Charizard ex is starker, since the Obsidian Flames print gems 22.16 percent against 39.88 for the shiny one. Two of the three shiny prints grade better than the card they reprint.

Mew is not a cursed subject either. The ultra rare Mew ex in 151 reads 38.14 percent, upper half of that set's twelve Pokemon ultra rares, and the gold hyper rare at 29.18 is the best of the three hyper rares printed beside it. Only the Ultra-Premium Collection promo at 17.86 percent does worse than this card, and that one has a pale border problem all of its own.

The trailing rate reads worse than it is. GemRate's thirty day figure here is 16 percent against the 32.8 lifetime, which looks like PSA tightening up on the card. Across the fifteen English rows printed in 2024 that have passed 20,000 grades, twelve carry a negative gap and the median gap is 19.96 points. This row's is smaller than typical.

A copy pulled from a Paldean Fates booster bundle in June 2025, submitted, and opened on camera when the grade came back. The reveal is the whole point of the census above.

USGMEN drew it, and nobody screened it

Scarlet and Violet Paldean Fates arrived on January 26, 2024, the English build of the Japanese High Class Pack Shiny Treasure ex released on December 1, 2023. Bulbapedia's page for the expansion counts three illustration rares, eight special illustration rares and six hyper rares, which matches the row counts in this dataset exactly, so the tier compared above is the whole tier.

The credit on 232 reads Illus. USGMEN. Of the seven prints this Mew ex card text has had, that artist drew one, and it is this one: shiny Mew is pale blue rather than pink, curled asleep inside a round bubble over a green hill, a Diglett and a Wooper watching from the grass below. The nickname wrote itself.

The census keeps a separate line for copies that came off the press with the texture missing, 14 of them on this card against 21 across the whole set. Far too few to read anything into, and a small sign that the texture press on this run was not perfectly steady.

The separation never shows up on the card face. Bubble Mew trades near $725 raw in November 2026 while the Iono out of the same tier trades near $21, and a card at the top of that spread gets mailed in by everyone who owns one rather than by people who checked it first. Census and price track each other closely inside a rarity tier while census and gem rate go nowhere, so call the submission pool the likeliest story in a weak field rather than the answer.

A $60 fee against a $2,190 ten

Grading mathAmount
Raw copy (live PriceCharting ungraded)$709
PSA grading, Standard service$60
PSA 10 sale (as of November 18, 2026, PriceCharting sold tape, PSA titled rows only)$2,190
PSA 9 sale (as of November 18, 2026, PriceCharting sold tape, PSA titled rows only)$725
Margin if it gems+$1,421
Margin at PSA 9-$44

Since November 1, 2026 the PSA titled sold tape medians $2,190 for a ten across 29 sales, $725 for a nine across 27, and $625 for an 8 across nine. Raw Near Mint copies median $725 across 38 sales in the same window. A nine and an unopened raw copy are the same money, which means the nine hands back the fee and nothing else.

PSA listed Standard at $59.99 on November 18, 2026, a $1,000 maximum insured value and 70 to 80 business days. That declared value covers the likely result and not the good one, since insuring a $2,190 ten means Express at $199.00.

Weight the four outcomes by the lifetime census and a submission grosses about $1,185. Take 15 percent off the far end for the eBay and shipping cut and it nets near $1,008 against roughly $785 of card plus Standard fee, an edge of about 28 percent, with breakeven at a 14.9 percent gem rate. Pay for Express so the ten is covered and breakeven moves to 26.1 percent. The lifetime rate clears both tiers. The trailing 16 percent clears only the cheaper one, by about thirteen dollars. PSA still returned 848 of these last period on a -5% pop trend, so the queue has not emptied.

If you are holding one

Check the centering before the fee, and use the art to do it. The white ring of the bubble is the one true circle on the card, so compare its gap to the left frame against its gap to the right, then the top against the bottom, and a cut that is drifting shows up without a loupe. Half of everything mailed in so far still came back a 9, so size the submission to that number rather than to the ten you want.

Buying the finished slab costs about three times the raw card and arrives this week instead of next spring. Sort the rest of the tier by gem rate, census and price in the BetterPop browser, or read what a pop report can and cannot tell you before deciding a 32.8 percent rate is good or bad news.

Sources

  • PSA population via the GemRate pull dated October 1, 2026 for this row; every token above refreshes with each site build. The tier figures, the fourteen set Pokemon versus Supporter comparison, the ultra rare tier ranges, the earlier print rates, the shiny subset census ranking and the 2024 trailing gap cohort were all computed from that same dataset, across every Pokemon row it tracks
  • Bulbapedia: Paldean Fates (TCG), read November 18, 2026, for the January 26, 2024 English release, the December 1, 2023 Japanese Shiny Treasure ex release, the rarity counts and the note that booster packs were sold only inside set related products
  • Bulbapedia: Mew ex (151 151), read November 18, 2026, for the seven prints of this card text and the USGMEN credit on the Paldean Fates special illustration rare
  • PriceCharting: Mew ex #232 Paldean Fates, sold tape read November 18, 2026. Medians are taken from PSA titled rows only, with CGC, BGS, SGC, TAG and ACE rows dropped, and every grade cut to the same window from November 1
  • PSA service levels, fees and turnaround, read November 18, 2026: Standard $59.99 at a $1,000 maximum insured value and 70 to 80 business days, Express $199.00 at $2,500
  • Card number, illustrator credit, 2024 copyright line and the shiny Mew artwork confirmed on the card scan itself

Every number above is one row of 111,891. Sort the whole census yourself, free, no login.

Open the BetterPop gallery