XY Evolutions M Charizard EX pop report: the full arts split in two

No English card printed between 2013 and 2016 has produced more Gem Mint 10s than this one. PSA has stamped 13,525 of them on M Charizard EX 101/108, the full art ultra rare from XY Evolutions, against 10,226 on the bordered print of the same card at the October 23, 2026 pull.

The XY Evolutions M Charizard EX pop report reads 39.0 percent across 34,637 grades. Eight other full arts came out of the same booster packs. Four finish between 35.63 and 40.38 percent, five between 26.51 and 30.40, and nothing lands in the five points between. All nine arrive at PSA in the same condition, which is the part worth explaining.

Thirteen thousand tens and the pile sitting under them

34,637 graded. 13,525 tens, 13,413 nines, 3,996 eights, 4 Authentic, and 3,699 copies finishing at a 7 or lower. PSA added 401 more last period on a thirty day trend of -2%.

Tens and nines sit within 112 copies of each other, close to a coin toss between the grade that pays and the grade that does not. The tail under them is short: 10.68 percent finished at a 7 or lower, against 12.11 percent pooled across the twenty three XY Evolutions rows past 5,000 grades, the lowest of any English 2016 set in the data. These copies are not arriving beaten up.

Nine full arts, and the gap sits in exactly one place

Line up all nine of the set's full art ultra rares at the October 23, 2026 pull and they fall into two groups that do not touch.

M Pidgeot EX 105 gems at 40.38 percent, M Venusaur EX 100 at 36.74 and M Blastoise EX 102 at 35.63, with this Charizard sitting among them at 39.0 percent. Pooled across 72,991 grades, 37.84 percent. Then Brock's Grit 107 at 30.40, Pidgeot EX 104 at 30.06, Dragonite EX 106 at 28.68, Mewtwo EX 103 at 27.03 and Misty's Determination 108 at 26.51. Pooled across 43,266 grades, 28.05 percent.

Now split both groups into the two things a gem rate is made of. The share of each census that came back below an 8 is 10.25 percent for the first group and 9.77 for the second, so the cards that gem worse are, if anything, the ones that arrived cleaner. Everything happens one rung higher. Of the copies that reached a 9 or a 10, the first group turned 48.70 percent into tens and the second turned 37.59. Nothing separates these cards on the way to PSA. They separate in front of the grader.

Two differences line up with that split and neither can be isolated. The first four are the Mega EX cards, all rendered by 5ban Graphics; the other five went to Ryo Ueda, Hitoshi Ariga and Megumi Mizutani. And in this set only, the two groups are physically different objects. Bulbapedia records that Evolutions rebuilt the Base Set layout and gave its Pokemon-EX a gold border, and on the scans that border sits on all five of the second group and on none of the first, whose artwork runs off the cut edge on every side.

Seven more XY sets, and the same rung

If the frame were doing it, the effect should be local, because Evolutions is the only XY set that bordered some full arts and not others. It is not local.

Take every XY set that printed full art ultra rares by both 5ban Graphics and Ryo Ueda, seven of them, and compare conversion from a 9 to a 10. The 5ban cards come out ahead in all seven: Fates Collide by 13.83 points, Evolutions by 10.80, Breakpoint by 7.28, Steam Siege by 7.25, Ancient Origins by 6.52, Breakthrough by 5.15 and Roaring Skies by 0.71, which is a coin flip and gets counted honestly. Pooled, 46.65 percent on 115,404 grades against 35.39 on 79,781.

Damage below an 8 goes both ways across those same seven, from 7.00 points of advantage in Roaring Skies to 1.44 of deficit in Steam Siege, so it is not a handling story anywhere. In the two sets where the 5ban cards finish with the lower overall gem rate they lose it on damage while still converting better at the top, which a single gem rate hides completely.

None of which proves the artist decides the grade. 5ban drew nearly every Mega EX of the era, so the studio and the card type cannot be pulled apart, and the only three of its XY full arts that are not Mega cards lean the same way without settling anything: Hoopa EX at 40.35 against Ancient Origins' 35.45, Volcanion EX and Magearna EX at 40.66 and 42.76 against Steam Siege's 39.60. The Blastoise ex 151 census runs the clean version of this test, seven painters inside one rarity tier, and there the whole group lands inside a spread of barely three points. For what a count like this can carry alone, start with what a pop report actually measures.

5ban drew it, and Japan had it first

The credit reads Illus. 5ban Graphics, a digital studio rather than a named illustrator, and it sits on all four prints of this card going back to Flashfire in 2014. The subject is Mega Charizard Y, mid roar, with the Japanese attack name burning across the middle in red and gold. Crimson Dive does 300 for five Energy and puts 50 back on itself, which Bulbapedia records as the first base attack of 300 printed in the game.

English XY Evolutions reached shelves on November 2, 2016, a 113 card set built for the twentieth anniversary; Japan had it first on September 16, where this print is 091 of 087 at SR rarity and the bordered 13/108 is 013 of 087 at RR. The rarer of the two leads the commoner one by 9,698 submissions, because a pop report counts what people chose to mail rather than what the press printed.

gregdoh pulls this exact print out of a Walgreens mystery box in March 2022, which is the moment every copy in the census below started from.

Nineteen percent to break even, eighteen on the trailing rate

Grading mathAmount
Raw copy (as of November 19, 2026)$122
PSA grading, Standard service$60
PSA 10 sale (as of November 19, 2026, the PSA titled sold tape)$560
PSA 9 sale (as of November 19, 2026, the PSA titled sold tape)$155
Margin if it gems+$378
Margin at PSA 9-$27

Twenty nine PSA 10 sales between November 5 and November 18, 2026 median $560.00 against PriceCharting's quoted $570.50, and twenty nine PSA 9 sales from November 3 to November 17 median $154.50 against $153.75. The raw figure is the one that needed replacing. That page's Ungraded column reads $67.50 because it pools played copies and openly damaged ones, including $34.99 sales titled DAMAGED, while thirty TCGplayer Near Mint sales since July 31, 2026 median $121.97. Pay the second number if you want a copy worth the fee.

PSA listed Standard at $59.99 on November 19, 2026, with a $1,000 maximum insured value and an estimated 70 to 80 business days. Value has reopened $20 cheaper, but it caps declared value at $500, and a 39.0 percent shot at a $560 slab does not belong under that ceiling.

Weight the outcomes by the census, take 15 percent off each payout for the sale, and $121.97 of card plus $59.99 of fee returns about $255 against $182 of cost. Breakeven sits near a 19 percent gem rate against a card gemming at 39.0 percent, which looks like a wide margin until you read the trailing figure. GemRate's thirty day gem rate here is 18 percent. All 46 English cards from this era past 5,000 grades trail their lifetime rate, median 9.07 points under, so the drop is ordinary; a drop landing on the breakeven is still the number to plan against.

The 9 is where the margin goes. At $154.50 against the raw copy and the fee it comes back about $27 short before eBay takes anything, and 38.72 percent of submissions receive it.

Screen it at the nine, not at the corners

Buy a copy you can see, and judge it on the grade you will probably get rather than the one on the price page. The damage question is settled before most copies reach PSA, and the money is decided between an 8 and a 10. With the artwork running to the cut on all four sides there is no frame to measure the front against, so the back carries more of the centering than it does on the set's bordered prints, and the front tell is whitening where the dark art stops at the edge. That order is how collectors who submit this print in volume describe it, not anything PSA publishes.

Before you pay for anything, put this row next to the two other Charizards out of these same packs. The holo rare gems near 1 percent and its reverse foil does six times better than that, which is three completely different answers from one booster box. Pull all three up together in the BetterPop gallery and decide which argument you are actually buying.

Sources

  • PSA population via the GemRate pull of October 23, 2026; every figure in the data block refreshes with each site build
  • The nine card split, the damage and conversion decomposition, the seven set XY comparison, the trailing rate control across 46 rows and the XY era PSA 10 ranking were all computed inside that same snapshot on November 19, 2026
  • Illustrator credits and rarity for every XY era full art via the TCGdex card records, read November 19, 2026, and confirmed on the card scans
  • PriceCharting: M Charizard EX #101, Pokemon Evolutions, price table and dated sold tape read November 19, 2026, filtered to PSA titled rows; the Near Mint raw median is that page's TCGplayer sales
  • PSA service levels, fees, maximum insured values and turnaround read off psacard.com/pricing on November 19, 2026
  • The 5ban Graphics credit, Crimson Dive, the Mega Charizard Y origin, the 300 damage note, the November 2 and September 16, 2016 release dates, the Japanese 091/087 SR number and the gold border on the set's Pokemon-EX via Bulbapedia's M Charizard-EX (Flashfire 13) and Evolutions (TCG) pages, read November 19, 2026
  • The border on each of the nine full arts was read off the high resolution scans directly

Every number above is one row of 111,891. Sort the whole census yourself, free, no login.

Open the BetterPop gallery