Dark Raichu pop report: the same bad answer from every press

PSA has graded the unlimited Dark Raichu 7,646 times and issued 33 Gem Mint tens. At the October 1, 2026 pull the Dark Raichu pop report reads 0.43 percent, against 1.40 percent pooled across the eighteen Team Rocket holos in that same printing.

Wizards of the Coast wrote this card into the set itself, numbered it 83 in an 82 card set, and put it in English packs ten weeks before Japan ever saw it. Four print runs of that drawing now have their own census, and every one of them finishes near the bottom of whatever group it sits in.

Where seven thousand submissions stopped

7,646 graded. 33 tens, 938 nines, 2,174 eights, and 4,472 copies finishing at a PSA 7 or lower, which is 58.49 percent of everything mailed in. PSA added 125 more last period on a thirty day trend of +15%.

The pile peaks at an 8 and then drops away. Of the copies that reached a 9 or a 10, 3.40 percent took the ten; the 1st Edition print of the same card converts that step at 10.29 percent, on 8,082 grades holding 246 tens. Splitting a gem rate into damage and conversion is usually how a card like this gives up its answer, and here both halves move at once, so neither one is the story on its own.

Everything above counts the unlimited print, the one with no Edition 1 stamp beside the Mouse Pokemon bar. The stamped print is a separate census, and crossing the two quotes a figure wrong by a factor of seven. If a census as a record of submissions rather than surviving cards is a new idea, start with what a population report actually counts.

Four censuses, three sets, two countries

Most of the grading mysteries on this blog resolve to the print run. A 2000 reprint grades worse than the 1999 original and the foil had changed between them. A reverse holo out of the same pack as a holo rare gems six times better, thirteen times out of thirteen. Swap the press and the number moves.

Dark Raichu does not do that. Rank each of its censuses against the holos it shipped alongside and it lands in the bottom four every time. Team Rocket unlimited: seventeenth of eighteen at 0.43 percent, with only Dark Magneton's 0.19 below it. Team Rocket 1st Edition: fifteenth of eighteen at 3.04. The Legendary Collection reprint from 2002, sixteenth of nineteen at 0.95 on 945 grades. The Japanese print in Crossing the Ruins, eighteenth of twenty at 16.00 on 1,881.

That last number deserves its own sentence, because 16.00 percent against 0.43 looks like an indictment of Wizards and is not one. The other nineteen holo rows in that Japanese set pool 18.94 percent across 44,182 grades, so the card sits below its setmates in Japan exactly as it does in English. The Pacific explains the level. It does not explain the rank.

One honest deduction before anyone reads too much into four bottom four finishes. Inside each of those groups, the most submitted cards gem worst, at rank correlations between minus 0.42 and minus 0.70, and this card is the fourth, fourth, eighth and eighth most submitted of its group. Some of its position is simply that everybody grades the secret card. What volume does not cover is the size of the fall: fourth by submissions and seventeenth of eighteen by rate is not a slope, it is a drop.

So the evidence points at the card rather than any one factory, and the census cannot say which part of the card. The dark artwork window is a tempting culprit and it has already failed its test: the eighteen Team Rocket holos pool to the same rate as the fifteen pale framed Base Set holos, to the second decimal. Whatever is wrong with this one is narrower than a frame.

The card Wizards wrote into its own set

Team Rocket reached English shelves on April 24, 2000, two and a half years behind the Japanese Rocket Gang set it was built from. Dark Raichu was not in that Japanese set. Bulbapedia records it as made especially for the English release by Wizards of the Coast, the only card in the game made completely by them, and credits Wizards with inventing the Secret card in the process: a collection number higher than the card count of the expansion it sits in. It reached Japan on July 7, 2000 in Crossing the Ruins, as a Super Rare, seventy four days after English players were already pulling it.

Mitsuhiro Arita signed the artwork. The card also shipped with a mistake nobody caught, the line across the top right reading "Put Raichu on the Basic Pokemon" instead of Dark Raichu, which the Legendary Collection reprint later fixed. Its evolution box interior is light grey rather than the dark grey every other Dark Pokemon in the set carries, and the reprint kept that. Bulbapedia also records, citing a MATOBA DESIGN page on the unfinished Jamboree project, that making this one card delayed the whole expansion by three months.

Binder Stories spends nine minutes on the numbering, the misprinted top line and the grey evolution box, which is most of what is strange about this card before anyone grades one.

A three thousand dollar ten that nobody should chase

Grading mathAmount
Raw copy (live TCGplayer market)$140
PSA grading, Value service$40
PSA 10 sale (as of November 15, 2026, PSA titled sold rows)$3,618
PSA 9 sale (as of November 15, 2026, PSA titled sold rows)$460
Margin if it gems+$3,438
Margin at PSA 9+$280

The ten barely trades. PriceCharting's tape carries five PSA 10 sales in its entire history: $474.69 in September 2022, $600.00 in October 2024, then $2,801.00 on August 25, 2025, $3,618.00 on February 22, 2026 and $7,877.77 on July 23, 2026. The figure in the table is the median of those last three. PriceCharting's algorithmic column reads $4,239.60, which is a guess set against five sales of evidence.

The grades people can actually buy, filtered to PSA titled rows and window matched from October 1 to November 15, 2026: a 9 medians $460.00 across seven sales, an 8 medians $228.98 across ten, a 7 medians $170.00 across eleven. Widen the 9 back to August and it reads $362.02 on fourteen, so that rung has climbed through the autumn. CGC and ACE copies share these listing titles and sell for less, and they are dropped from every figure here.

Now run the submission. Weighting every rung of this census by its own 2026 median returns $188.13 a card gross, about $160 after a 15 percent haircut for fees and shipping, against $139.71 of raw card plus $39.99 of PSA Value service. Roughly twenty dollars of loss per attempt. Breakeven needs a 1.11 percent gem rate and the card returns 0.43 percent, and the answer stays negative even if every ten is priced at the record $7,877.77.

One oddity falls out of the same tape. Ten PSA 1 copies sold in 2026 at a $110.00 median, above the PSA 3, 4 and 5 medians of $51.00, $63.98 and $68.85. The cheapest slabbed route into a famous card looks like it gets bid on as a label rather than as a grade, though ten sales is thin ground for saying so.

Nothing here says mail it

Buy the grade you want already finished. An 8 near $229 and a 9 near $460 both beat paying $180 for a lottery ticket and 90 to 100 business days of queue. If you are buying raw anyway, look past the yellow border at the confetti holo field behind Raichu, because that dark background is where the press lines and pack scuffs that cap this census at a 9 show up first. Every row quoted above refreshes itself in the BetterPop gallery, and a population this thin does not behave like ordinary scarcity.

Sources

  • Population figures: GemRate PSA population data, pull dated October 1, 2026. All set, rank and correlation comparisons were computed inside that one snapshot on November 15, 2026.
  • Card history, release dates, the Secret card mechanic, the misprinted top line, the grey evolution box and the three month delay: Bulbapedia, Dark Raichu (Team Rocket 83), Team Rocket (TCG), and Neo Discovery (TCG), which carries the Crossing the Ruins release date, all read November 15, 2026. The delay claim is Bulbapedia's, cited there to a MATOBA DESIGN page on the Jamboree project.
  • Prices: PriceCharting, Dark Raichu #83 Pokemon Team Rocket, grade columns and full sold tape read November 15, 2026, filtered to PSA titled rows. The raw figure in the table is the live TCGplayer market price; ten TCGplayer Near Mint sales since August 1, 2026 medianed $135.00, while PriceCharting's ungraded column reads $67.23 because it averages in played copies.
  • Grading fees and turnaround: PSA pricing, read November 15, 2026. Value $39.99 at a $500 maximum insured value and 90 to 100 business days, Standard $59.99 at $1,000 and 70 to 80 days, Priority $79.99 at $1,500 and 50 to 60 days.

Every number above is one row of 111,891. Sort the whole census yourself, free, no login.

Open the BetterPop gallery